Internal auditing should not be perceived as internal spying, but rather as a tool that encourages the exchange of viewpoints in order to improve the QMS or the process. The auditor, and the way they perform this role, plays a key part in how this assessment is perceived by the auditees.
The internal audit is carried out step by step, and every step matters, from preparation to the presentation of the report and the follow-up of corrective actions. If any step is poorly performed, the result will inevitably be of little value to the department or the personnel concerned.
8.8 - Internal Audit
8.8.1 The laboratory shall conduct internal audits at planned intervals to provide information to determine whether the management system:
a) conforms to:
the laboratory's own requirements for its management system, including
laboratory activities, and the requirements of this International Standard;
b) is effectively implemented and maintained.
8.8.2 The laboratory shall:
a) plan, establish, implement, and maintain an audit program covering,
in particular, the frequency, methods, responsibilities, planning requirements,
and reporting.
The audit program shall take into account the importance of the laboratory
activities concerned, changes affecting the laboratory, and the results
of previous audits;
b) define the audit criteria and scope for each audit;
c) ensure that audit results are reported to the relevant management;
d) undertake correction and appropriate corrective actions without undue
delay; and
e) retain records as evidence of the implementation of the audit program
and of the audit results.
![]()
Definition of a Quality Audit: a systematic, independent, and documented process for obtaining audit evidence and evaluating it objectively to determine the extent to which audit criteria are fulfilled.
Planned intervals do not necessarily mean every year. If the audit performed by the notified body resulted in only a few non-critical findings one or two, for example or if your QMS has been mature for several years and this is reflected positively in the number of formalized findings, I believe you can justify a longer interval for performing your internal audit, such as 15 months, 18 months, or even 2 years, unless CAB imposes a different interpretation of this clause, which is not currently the case.
A procedure is not mandatory.
Not all elements of the QMS will necessarily be audited. Previous
audits, customer audits, changes, modifications, implementation of new
equipment, new personnel, and similar factors must be taken into account.
The laboratory quality manager is responsible for planning and organizing
internal audits according to predefined programs and based on management
requests.
Audits must be performed by trained and qualified personnel who are
not directly involved in the activities being audited, provided this
is compatible with the laboratory’s available human resources.
If, as a result of these audits, doubts arise regarding the proper operation
of the laboratory or the accuracy or validity of test results, the laboratory
must promptly undertake the necessary corrective actions and inform
the customer concerned in writing, in cases where the results provided
may have been negatively affected.
The laboratory must provide evidence of the training of internal auditors.
Note: audits performed by a third party within the company are generally limited to document traceability. The audit is performed because it is a normative requirement, but unfortunately, in most cases, it does not focus on critical findings due to a lack of technical knowledge on the part of the evaluators.
My experience shows that an external audit performed by someone who
actually practices the same tests provided, of course, that the person
is an expert in the field is certainly more expensive, but far more
beneficial for everyone involved. The level of improvement is not comparable.
Internal auditing is an effective tool used for the CAB's self-assessment
and for determining the extent to which the QMS requirements are fulfilled.
The audit results, or evaluation findings, must demonstrate the effectiveness
of the QMS and identify nonconformities and opportunities for improvement.
The CAB must define, implement, and maintain an internal audit program.
An audit program is a series of steps or specifications required by
the CAB in order to conduct the audit.
The purpose of the program is to identify the departments, personnel,
activities, and tests that will be audited and to determine when they
will be audited.
It must establish:
The frequency and intervals of audits;
The methods used to conduct the audit;
The roles and responsibilities of personnel involved in the internal
audit;
The time requirements for completion;
The reporting of results.
The CAB must define the scope or extent of the audit, including activities,
topics, departments, locations, responsibilities, processes, or the
specific status of processes.
By being issued and made available, the program enables personnel to
understand that internal auditing is a continuous measure of the QMS
and not an arbitrary decision made by management.
The program must specify the auditor or audit team, specific roles,
management representatives, technical experts, and so on.
The program must detail the resources required for the audit, such as
meeting rooms, personnel, records, tests, and other necessary resources.
The program must provide a description of the agenda or of the topics
and questions that will be audited and discussed.
The program must indicate the planned timelines for the different stages
of the audit.
The results must include a reference to:
The importance of the processes, where applicable, as well as the activities
or operations audited;
Changes that may affect, or have affected, the organization;
The results of previous audits and the status of previous findings,
including internal audits, third-party audits, customer audits, and
others.
The CAB must define the audit criteria. Audit criteria are a set of
policies, procedures, or requirements used as a reference against which
audit evidence is compared.
The CAB must select auditors and perform the audit in a way that ensures
the objectivity and impartiality of the audit process.
The CAB must ensure that audit results are communicated to management.
The CAB must ensure that nonconformities are addressed and that corrective
actions are implemented within a reasonable timeframe.
The CAB must retain documented information and evidence relating to
audit conclusions and results, including information on the implementation
of actions following the audit results. The audited areas of activity,
audit results, and the related corrections and corrective actions must
be documented.
During an initial accreditation, the CAB will not be able to conduct a partial internal audit, as it has no prior data on the quality of its QMS.
![]()
Internal audit must evaluate the effectiveness of risk management processes and contribute to their improvement.
Interpretation:
To determine whether risk management processes are effective, internal
auditors must ensure that:
the organizations objectives are consistent with, and contribute to,
its mission;
significant risks are identified and assessed;
the selected risk treatment methods are appropriate and aligned with
the OEC risk appetite;
risk-related information is collected and communicated in a timely manner
within the OEC, enabling employees and their management to fulfill their
responsibilities.
To support this assessment, internal audit may rely on information obtained
from various engagements.
A consolidated view of the results of these engagements provides an
understanding of the OEC risk management process and its effectiveness.
Risk management processes are monitored through ongoing management activities,
specific evaluations, or both.
Document to be consulted: ISO 19011