DemarcheISO17025
  • Home
  • PREVIOUS
Loss of Impartiality

Loss of Impartiality

The causes of loss of impartiality are numerous and may be either direct or subtle.

Definitions

Definitions Related to Impartiality

A few definitions to reinforce certain principles that should be promoted and applied by personnel who may be exposed to risks of compromising impartiality.

4.1 - Impartiality

4.1 Impartiality
4.1.1 Laboratory activities shall be undertaken impartially and structured and managed so as to safeguard impartiality.
4.1.2 Laboratory management shall be committed to impartiality.
4.1.3 The laboratory shall be responsible for the impartiality of its laboratory activities and shall not allow commercial, financial or other pressures to compromise impartiality.
4.1.4 The laboratory shall identify risks to its impartiality on an ongoing basis. This shall include those risks that arise from its activities, or from its relationships, or from the relationships of its personnel. However, such relationships do not necessarily present a laboratory with a risk to impartiality.
4.1.5 If a risk to impartiality is identified, the laboratory shall be able to demonstrate how it eliminates or minimizes such risk.

Methodology

This requirement has always been part of laboratory practice. Even before accreditation became a consideration, the fundamental responsibility of an analyst was—and still is—to provide results that are as technically representative as possible while maintaining the highest standards of ethical integrity.

Today, some studies funded by special interest groups (lobbying organizations) may produce technically valid results. However, the interpretation of those results, or the way samples are collected, can lead to radically different conclusions, potentially seriously compromising the impartiality of the study.

Fortunately, the vast majority of laboratories are not exposed to such external pressures. Nevertheless, a laboratory may unknowingly contribute to such a situation when its role is limited to providing test results without interpretation, leaving the final conclusions to the client.
How can laboratories meet this requirement?

Several tools can help fulfill this obligation:
- The Conformity Assessment Body's (CAB) policy: First and foremost, top management should formally commit to impartiality through the organization's policy, if such a commitment has not already been established.
- A code of ethics and professional conduct: Establish a code of ethics signed and dated by every staff member and by management.
- Internal workplace rules and regulations: In larger organizations, these generally already include confidentiality obligations, although impartiality is not always explicitly addressed.
- Job descriptions: Although formal job descriptions are no longer an explicit requirement, they may include a section addressing employees' ethical and professional responsibilities, regardless of their position or role.

Laboratory-Specific Code of Ethics:

This code establishes the rules of professional ethics and conduct applicable to all laboratory personnel regarding independence, impartiality, integrity, and confidentiality.

- Maintain the highest standards of integrity, acting fairly and responsibly toward all parties concerned.
- Demonstrate impartiality by remaining free from prejudice, bias, or favoritism.
- Comply with, and ensure compliance with, applicable regulations, standards, and documents (procedures, work instructions, forms, etc.) governing the inspections and tests for which they are responsible.
- Reject any influence or pressure (commercial, financial, or otherwise) exerted by any party on laboratory activities. The laboratory and its personnel shall maintain technical independence and ensure that test results are based solely on technical considerations.
- Immediately report any conflicts of interest, particularly those arising from personal or professional relationships.
- Refrain from disclosing test results, documents, or information obtained from clients to individuals outside the company without the formal consent of both the clients concerned and management.
- Treat all technical and other information obtained during testing activities as confidential.
- Immediately inform management of any circumstances that could prevent compliance with the obligations outlined above.

The laboratory's organizational structure and implemented measures are designed to safeguard impartiality and independence. In particular:

- Personnel compensation shall not depend on the number of tests performed or the results obtained.
- Personnel shall not engage in any other activities that could undermine confidence in their competence, impartiality, judgment, or operational integrity.


Date and Signatures

The assessment of risks to impartiality will be carried out using a risk assessment table, which will be updated as often as necessary, with an annual review conducted as part of the management review.

The content of this table is not exhaustive. Each conformity assessment body (CAB) will face both generic risks and risks specific to its own organizational structure and operating practices.

However, a CAB should not turn into a police investigation unit. The risk assessment should be limited to straightforward, relevant questions without intruding into employees' private lives, except where potential relationships with clients, competitors, suppliers, or other interested parties could present a risk to impartiality.

Activities / Parties Type of Relationship Associated Risks Initial Risk Level Measures / Actions to Control Risks

Monitoring / Frequency Residual Risk Level

Management / Parent Company / Shareholders

Hierarchical

Financial pressure

Influence on test results

High

Management and personnel commitment Independence of departments

Personnel awareness training

Code of ethics

Annual performance review Management review

Reporting of concerns

Internal audits

Low
External Clients

Commercial Personal

Influence on test results High

Management and personnel commitment

Personnel awareness training

Code of ethics

Annual performance review

Management review

Reporting of concerns

Internal audits

Low
Employees

ersonal relationships

Clients

Competitors

Loss of objectivity

Loss of impartiality

High

Management and personnel commitment

Personnel awareness training

Code of ethics

Self-checking

Annual performance review

Reporting of concerns

Internal audits

Review of test reports

Supervision

Low
Suppliers

Commercial

Personal

Nonconforming products

Dependence on a single supplier

Loss of objectivity

Low

Purchasing department oversight

Supplier evaluation

Code of ethics

Annual performance review

Management review

Reporting of concerns

Internal audits

 
Low
Internal Clients Technical Loss of impartiality Medium

Management and personnel commitment

Code of ethics

Personnel awareness training

Independence of departments

eporting of concerns

Annual performance review

Management review

Internal audits

Low
Copyright © DemarcheISO17025.com